American Lawn Mower 1204-14 Push Reel Mower Review
When you buy through the Amazon links on this page, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Last updated October 31, 2026
The American Lawn Mower 1204-14 is a good buy for a small, flat, smooth lawn kept short, and a frustrating one for a big, rough, or overgrown yard. It weighs 19 lb, runs on nothing but your legs, and snips grass against a bed knife instead of tearing it, which is why it is quiet and easy to push on level ground.
It suits a front yard, a side yard, a path, or a second patch of grass you want to keep tidy without gas or a cord. Skip it if your lawn is large, your grass is coarse or kept tall, your ground is bumpy or sloped, or you want to bag or mulch clippings.
Where the 1204-14 Earns Its Keep on Your Lawn
The 1204-14 keeps things simple, and that simplicity is where most of its strengths come from.
Light and easy to push
At 19 lb, the mower rolls with little resistance on flat ground. Buyers on Amazon most often praise ease of use, and weight is one of the topics they raise positively.
Quiet, gas-free operation
There is no engine, no fuel, and no cord. The manual reel design is quiet enough to mow early in the morning or late in the evening without bothering anyone, and the manual design is what keeps running costs down to the occasional sharpening.
A clean scissor cut
The 4-blade tempered steel reel works against a bed knife and snips each blade of grass like a pair of scissors. That is the cut the product advertises as healthier for the lawn, and it is the reason a reel mower leaves a tidier finish than a rotary on fine turf.
Quick to assemble and easy to store
Buyers on Amazon rate assembly positively, and the mower goes together with basic tools. The T-style handle folds down, and the footprint of 20 inches wide, 24 inches deep, and 42.5 inches high lets it hang on a wall or fit in a trunk.
Few parts to fail
No gas, oil, spark plug, or battery means upkeep is limited to occasional adjustment and sharpening. Buyers on Amazon also rate value for money positively, which fits a manual mower with so little to go wrong.
The Trade-Offs You Accept With the 1204-14
The same design that makes the 1204-14 light and quiet also sets hard limits on what it can cut.
A short cutting height only
The adjustable range runs from 0.5 to 1.75 inches. That suits closely kept turf, but it sits below the 2 to 3 inches most lawns are best maintained at, so this is a short-grass tool rather than an all-purpose mower. Grass that is too long lies over instead of being cut.
A narrow 14-inch cut
Expect more passes and more walking time than a wider mower. On anything but a small lawn, the extra passes add up quickly.
No bagging or mulching
The mower is sold as the mower only, and clippings drop behind it. A grass collection accessory is compatible but sold separately, and there is no mulching function, so long grass leaves clumps on the lawn.
Tall, wet, or debris-laden grass stops it
Buyers on Amazon are divided on cutting performance and pushability: some say it cuts well and pushes easily on flat ground, while others report uneven cuts and real effort. The complaint that comes up most among them is the mower getting stuck on small sticks and grass that is too high.
Height changes need tools
Changing the cut height means loosening and retightening hardware, not flipping a lever. Pick a height and stay with it.
It needs flat, smooth ground
Bumps, roots, and slopes lift the wheels, and when the wheels lose contact the reel stops cutting cleanly. The small wheels also do not roll well over rough ground.
An uncut strip at edges
The reel sits inboard of the wheels, so fences and walls need a trimmer afterward.
Exposed blades and real upkeep
The blades are exposed, so handle the mower with care during assembly, adjustment, and storage. The bed knife needs periodic adjustment and the reel occasional sharpening, with a sharpening and maintenance accessory and the SK-2 hand sharpener compatible with it and sold separately.
The product in this review
American Lawn Mower 1204-14
See on AmazonThe 1204-14 by the Numbers Before You Commit
These are the figures that decide whether the 1204-14 fits your yard.
| Specification | Value |
|---|---|
| Type | Push reel mower, manual, 4-blade reel |
| Cutting width | 14 inches |
| Cutting height | 0.5 to 1.75 inches, adjustable |
| Blade material | Tempered 65Mn steel |
| Wheels | 8.5 inches |
| Weight | 19 lb |
| Dimensions | 20 inches wide, 24 inches deep, 42.5 inches high |
| Color and material | Red, alloy steel |
| In the box | Reel mower only |
| Compatible accessories, sold separately | Grass collection accessory, blade touch-up accessory, blade sharpening and maintenance accessory, storage accessory, SK-2 hand sharpener |
What the specs mean in use
The 14-inch figure is nominal, so expect a slightly narrower real cut and a few more passes than the number suggests. The 0.5 to 1.75-inch range confirms this is a short-turf mower. And reel mower only means no catcher in the box, so plan on the collection accessory if you want the clippings picked up.
Setup, adjustment, and upkeep
A little setup and a yearly habit keep the 1204-14 cutting cleanly.
Assembly
Attach the handle with basic tools and check that the reel spins freely before the first cut. Assembly is quick, and buyers on Amazon rate it positively.
Height adjustment
Set the cut height before you mow. It is a hardware-loosening job, so choose a height that suits your turf and leave it there.
Bed-knife adjustment
This is the core maintenance task. The cutter bar must sit close enough to the reel to snip paper cleanly across the full width, but not so tight that pushing gets hard. Too loose and you get uncut strips; too tight and the mower drags and wears faster.
Sharpening
Sharpening is occasional rather than seasonal. A sharpening and maintenance accessory and the SK-2 hand sharpener are compatible and sold separately.
Clearing a jam
Stop, tip the mower, and clear sticks and clumps by hand, keeping your hands away from the exposed blades.
Storage
Fold the handle and hang the mower or tuck it into a corner. A storage accessory is compatible and sold separately.
Mowing rhythm
Mow often at a steady walking pace. Reel cut quality depends on pace and on the wheels staying on the ground, so short, regular cuts beat one long session.
The American Lawn Mower 1204-14 is a well-made, light, quiet reel mower that is a genuinely good buy for a small, flat, short-cut lawn or a secondary area, and the wrong mower for big, rough, tall, or coarse-grass yards. If your yard is small and smooth and you want a gas-free cut without the noise, it does the job; if you need to bag, mulch, or cover ground quickly, look elsewhere. The product card shows the current price.
Frequently asked questions
A reel mower only cuts cleanly while its wheels stay on the ground and the grass stays short, which is why most questions about this model come back to lawn size, grass height, and terrain.
What cutting height range does the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 offer?
The lowest setting is 0.5 inch and the highest is 1.75 inches, adjusted with hardware rather than a lever, so you pick one height and keep it. Grass taller than the top of that range folds over ahead of the reel instead of being snipped.
Can the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 collect or mulch clippings?
No catcher ships in the box, so clippings fall out behind the mower and you rake them up yourself. There is no mulching function either, so tall grass is left in clumps rather than chopped fine and returned to the lawn.
How does the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 handle small sticks and overgrown grass?
Buyers on Amazon most often complain that this mower gets stuck on small sticks and on grass that has grown too tall. Because the reel scissors grass against a bed knife, long blades fold down rather than getting sliced.
Is the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 suited to a bumpy or sloped yard?
No, it is built for level ground. Roots, dips, and slopes lift the 8.5-inch wheels, and once the wheels leave the ground the reel stops cutting cleanly. On uneven ground you also end up pushing harder and getting an uneven cut, so a bumpy or sloped yard is better served by a rotary mower.
How does the 4-blade reel of the American Lawn Mower 1204-14 compare with the 5-blade models in the lineup?
The manufacturer's blade-count guide pairs the 4-blade 1204-14 with medium-texture grass on regularly maintained lawns. The 5-blade versions in the same family, at 14, 16, and 18 inches, are aimed at thick, less-maintained grass.